You can’t tell whether the candidate across the table is brilliant or bluffing, and the person you hire will own your payables, your month-end numbers or your CRA remittances. That is a common spot for owners, operations leads and HR managers across Kitchener-Waterloo, Hamilton, Burlington, Mississauga and Niagara. You don’t need to speak fluent accounting to run a good finance interview. You need a plan, and you need to judge how a candidate explains and decides rather than how many terms they can recite.
In our experience, hiring managers without a finance background tend to over-credit confident delivery and under-credit plain, careful answers. A structure fixes that. It lets you compare candidates fairly, even when the technical detail goes over your head.
Define the Finance Role Before You Interview Anyone
You can’t recognize a good answer until you know what the job requires. Before the first interview, write down what this person will actually own. “Accounting” is too vague. Be specific about the work.
- Which tasks are theirs outright: payables, receivables, payroll inputs, month-end close, bank reconciliations, HST filings, T4 preparation or CRA remittances?
- Who sees their output: ownership, a lender, a board, an outside accountant?
- Does this person work alone, or will they hand work to an external CPA firm at year-end?
Next, separate must-haves from nice-to-haves. A CPA Ontario designation belongs in the must-have column only if the role truly requires it, such as signing off on certain engagements or leading a team of accountants. For a standalone bookkeeping or accounting seat, demonstrated experience with your type of transactions often matters more than letters after a name. Listing a designation as mandatory when it isn’t can shrink your candidate pool and push your salary expectations higher than the role needs.
Finally, decide how the role fits your team and who they will report to. A technically strong person who dislikes being questioned by a non-finance owner will struggle in a small company. Knowing the working relationship in advance lets you judge style, not just skill. If the seat is a growing function rather than a one-person show, the thinking in this piece on a proven finance team structure for growth can help you see where this hire sits.
Copy this short checklist into your interview notes:
- The three to five tasks this person owns from day one
- The deliverables and deadlines tied to those tasks
- Must-have experience and credentials, with a reason for each
- Nice-to-haves you would trade for strong fit
- Reporting line and the one person who will manage them daily
- Work model: in-office, hybrid or remote, and the commute you can reasonably expect from a candidate
Finance Interview Questions That Work for Non-Finance Hiring Managers
The best questions for a non-specialist are open and ask the candidate to walk through real work. You are not testing whether they can define accruals. You are listening to how they think when something goes sideways, because in finance something always does.
Here are sample questions, grouped by what each one reveals.
Questions that reveal depth of real experience
- “Tell me about a month-end close that went wrong and what you did about it.”
- “Walk me through your process from the day an invoice arrives to the day it is paid and recorded.”
Questions that reveal whether they can communicate with non-finance colleagues
- “Explain a report you produced to someone who doesn’t work in finance. Pretend I’m that person.”
- “Tell me about a time a colleague pushed back on a number or a deadline. How did you handle it?”
Questions that reveal judgment tied to your business
- “A manager approves a vendor invoice a week late and the vendor is threatening to stop supply. What do you do?”
- “You discover a payroll error after a pay run has gone out. Walk me through the next 24 hours.”
Questions that reveal integrity and ownership
- “Describe a time you found a mistake you made. Who did you tell, and when?”
- “Have you ever been asked to book something you were uncomfortable with? What happened?”
Adapt these to your business. If you run a contractor with job costing, ask about job costing. If you are a distributor, ask about inventory counts and supplier terms. The more closely a question matches a task they will actually do, the more useful the answer.
What Good Answers Sound Like and What to Watch For
You can’t verify every technical claim, but you can hear whether an answer holds together. Strong candidates tend to do four things:
- They give a specific example with a beginning, a problem and an outcome, rather than a general statement about how they “always” work.
- They explain in plain language and check that you are following.
- They say what they would escalate and to whom, instead of claiming they handle everything alone.
- They admit what they don’t know and describe how they would find out.
Vague answers are the clearest warning. “We streamlined the close” with no description of what changed, who did it or how long it took usually means the candidate observed the work rather than did it. Listen for “we” with no “I” anywhere in the story. Ask a follow-up: “What was your part in that?” A person who did the work will answer without strain.
Also watch for answers that sound technical but never land on a decision. Jargon that doesn’t resolve into a clear action is a signal, not a credential. A good candidate can tell you what they did, why, and what they would do differently.
One limit to keep in mind: this approach tells you a lot about judgment, communication and honesty, but it can’t confirm technical accuracy. A fluent, well-organized candidate can still have gaps in the finer points of HST treatment or payroll compliance. That is why the next step matters.
Check Fit, Integrity and How They Work With Non-Finance Colleagues
Finance staff handle sensitive information and often work with little oversight, so character carries more weight here than in most roles. In a one-person accounting function, nobody reviews the books line by line. Reliability is the control.
Ask about how they handle confidential information such as payroll data, and how they respond when a senior person asks them to speed something up. Ask what they need from the rest of the business to do their job well: timely expense submissions, approvals, access to contracts. People who have worked closely with operations teams answer this easily and without complaint. People who see non-finance colleagues as obstacles will tell you so in different words.
Pay attention to how they treat the conversation itself. Do they ask you questions about the role, the systems in place and the current state of the books? Candidates who ask about the quality of the existing records, the reporting cycle and who makes decisions are thinking like owners of the function. That curiosity is worth more than a polished pitch. For a view of what experienced finance leaders look for beyond credentials, see this look at what CFOs really demand in finance talent.
Bring in a Second Set of Eyes Where It Helps
You don’t have to carry the technical evaluation alone. If you work with an outside accountant, ask them to join a second interview or to review a short work sample, such as a reconciliation exercise built from anonymized records. A trusted CPA can confirm in thirty minutes what you can’t judge in three interviews.
Whoever joins, keep the roles clear. You assess fit, communication and judgment. They assess technical depth. Compare notes afterward using the same checklist you wrote at the start, so each candidate is measured against the role rather than against the most charming person you met that week.
Speed matters too. Strong finance candidates in Ontario are usually weighing more than one offer, and a slow process loses people. If you suspect your own process is the bottleneck, this guide on whether your hiring process is built for the Ontario accounting talent market is a useful check.
Turn Your Interview Notes Into a Confident Decision
Score each candidate against your written checklist: role fit, quality of examples, clarity of explanation, judgment on your scenarios and working style with your team. Where two candidates are close, let the second technical opinion and your read on integrity break the tie. If no one clears your must-haves, widen the search rather than lowering the bar on a seat where one error touches every number you report.
If you would rather not run this alone, our consultants at Elby Professional Recruitment speak with Ontario Controllers, Accounting Managers and Bookkeepers every day, and we can bring you a shortlist of pre-vetted finance professionals who have already confirmed interest in your role, work model and pay range. To start, request talent through Elby and tell us what the seat needs to own.